Kentucky UMC Social Media Policy Requires Access to Pastors’ MySpace, Facebook Accounts

kentucky UMC logoIn a move that screams “we fear what we do not understand” the Kentucky Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church is requiring its clergy to sign a “MySpace, Facebook and Website Disclosure Agreement.”

The agreement requires clergy to “agree to allow the Kentucky Annual Conference to examine any and all MySpace, Facebook, or other blog and website accounts that I may have.”

While the agreement clearly requires access to all text and media posted publicly to social media accounts, it’s not clear whether it requires access to private messages. The document says, it gives the KY conference permission to “examine any and all … accounts” and “access to any part of these accounts will not be blocked.”  “Any part of these accounts” could reasonably interpreted to include private messages.

A person has to wonder, however, whether the people who wrote the document and implemented the policy have much familiarity with social media.  The policy is awfully concerned about MySpace, which hardly anyone still uses. The document also states the Kentucky Annual Conference can be found on Facebook at bom@kyumc.org. Really? It also asks for the pastor’s Facebook user name. Facebook doesn’t use usernames, unless you consider that to be the part of the URL that follows http://facebook.com/

I’m all for personal accountability, but for the most part accountability is a natural part of social media. People know what they write on their blogs and post to social media is going to be seen by the family, friends, and people in their church they’re connected with online. And in the event of a momentary lack of judgment, I expect one of them would do as Jesus instructed in Matthew 18:15 and send their pastor a quick message asking, “Do you really want to say that publicly?”

What do you think of this policy? Good accountability? Overreaching?

Paul Steinbrueck is co-founder and CEO of OurChurch.Com, husband, father of 3, blogger. You can follow him on Twitter at @PaulSteinbrueck and add him to your circles at Google+ as +Paul Steinbrueck.

18 Responses to “Kentucky UMC Social Media Policy Requires Access to Pastors’ MySpace, Facebook Accounts”

  1. Wow! What great debate that can come out of this. And from so many angles; world, spiritual, personal freedom, accountability, representation, etc.

    My short answer is this is overreaching and the Kentucky UMC should not put their clergy in such a position. Rules like this are of the world and Mark 12:17 comes to mind.

    17Jesus said to them, “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”

    Ultimately we are accountable to God.

  2. I am guessing this came as a reaction to some "scandal" that conference had regarding a Pastor and their Social Media account… I can see where they are coming from… and realistically any Pastor who is participating in Social Media shouldn't really have a problem with this. They really should be doing things that are already public anyway. That would be the point of using Social Media, right? 🙂

    Any Pastor who is doing things in secret probably isn't doing the "right" thing anyway… and they definitely need to realize that whatever they do on FB/Twitter, etc is PUBLIC for the world to see… 🙂

    Patrick Steil
    ChurchBuzz.org

  3. In an article – http://umportal.org/article.asp?id=8000 – from a United Methodist magazine (who bothered to talk to the conference about the policy before reporting on it) an representative from the conference is quoted as saying:

    “I’ve been surprised by all this,” said the Rev. Tom Grieb, chairman of the Kentucky Annual Conference’s Board of Ordained Ministry, which adopted the policy. “We haven’t had any pushback from our ordination candidates.”

    Is it reasonable to expect candidates for ordination to push back? When someone is seeking ordination from a Board of Ordained Ministry (yes the acronym is "boom") they aren't predisposed to make waves.

    In my opinion the policy seems over-reaching in the absence of a problem or accusation. Do conferences ask for newspaper clippings of every time candidates have been quoted in a news paper (they still have those right)?

  4. forgot to subscribe to replys. sorry for the double post. 🙂

  5. My personal opinion is that I do believe there should be some monitoring but not to the extreme of reading private messages …here is my example …if I am having a day and need someone to vent to its my pastor and what advice he gives me is between him and I. If I wanted the whole world to see my problems or a board of people I would've sent it to the board. Pastors even though they are "the door" to the spirit. They are human, they are of the flesh, they have reached a lot of youth and saved a lot of people becuase of social networking. They have a right to use things and reach out the public just as well as anyone. It's a touchy subject becuase I understand that they don't want pastors looking at things they shouldnt but honestly if you have the internet its there …and its not fair to take internet away from pastors who use to reach out to help people and bring them to God. I pray for all clergy around the world they have a big job, one that is not on the easiest top 10 list. Thank God for that.

  6. It definitely sounds like a knee jerk reaction (by social media neanderthals)to scandalous activities reported by the mainstream media of other churches. I would argue there still needs to be some level of trust and privacy thrust upon those being placed into positions of responsibility. It's sad that it has come to this level.

  7. while at first thought it may appear as overreaching, as far as for ministry i think it is a good idea.. ministry leaders should be held to a higher standard.. there is a lot of one thing on the platform and another online..

    however, if it gets to reaching into the pews.. then its too much.. judgement comes from God not men.

  8. The e-mail address they request you to friend on Facebook takes you to a conference employee's Facebook account. However, it appears that this person has a separate personal Facebook account, which is a violation of Facebook's Terms of Service. I continue to be amazed that this is not brought up by the press, though a few bloggers have mentioned it.

  9. Rev.wolff bachner Reply Jul 6, 2011 at 7:19 am

    i will be blunt. this is fascism. period.

  10. I think it show a remarkable lack of trust.
    Someone in Kentucky has way too much time on their hands.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Kentucky UMC Goes a Little Overboard | Unsettled Christianity - Jul 6, 2011

    […] via Kentucky UMC Social Media Policy Requires Access to Pastors’ MySpace, Facebook Accounts | Christia…. […]

  2. Does Your Organization Need a Social Media Policy? | Christian Web Trends Blog - Aug 31, 2011

    […] example is that of the Kentucky Conference of the United Methodist Church. They require clergy to “agree to allow the Kentucky Annual […]

Leave a Reply

What is 6 + 8 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)